2012-11-28 By D.K. Matai
As China’s military and economic influence has grown throughout the world, Beijing appears to have become bolder, brasher and more brazen in its claim to territories believed to be rich with oil and natural gas across the Asia-Pacific.
The latest attempt to achieve just that is the watermark on China’s new e-passports depicting its map, which has ended up insulting and offending most of its sovereign neighbors.
The map shows disputed islands in the South China Sea as Chinese territory.
Three separate pages in the new e-passports include China’s so-called “nine-dash” map of the sea that extends hundreds of miles south from China’s Hainan Island to the equatorial waters off the coast of Borneo.
The map includes the Spratly island chain, which is the subject of overlapping claims by five other countries including:
- Malaysia; and
- The Philippines.
As if that was not enough, China’s newly launched e-passport map also shows India’s Arunachal Pradesh and Aksai Chin — within the Ladakh region — in Jammu & Kashmir as parts of China.
Japan, at the same time, is embroiled in its own dispute with China over islands in the East China Sea.
All these simultaneous territorial spats have raised concerns about a potential conflict, prompting the United States to wade into the controversy.
Stand-offs between Chinese vessels and the Philippine and Vietnamese navies in the South China Sea have become much more common as China increases patrols in these waters believed to hold vast reserves of oil and natural gas.
There are concerns that those maritime disputes could escalate into violence. China and the Philippines had a tense maritime standoff at a shoal west of the main Philippine island of Luzon earlier this year.
The United States, which has said it takes no sides in the territorial spats, considers ensuring safe maritime traffic in the waters to be in its national interest. The US has backed a call for a “code of conduct” to prevent clashes in the disputed territories.
When one rewinds back to the days of the Cold War, there was a clear “code of conduct” between Eastern-Bloc and Western-Bloc ships. When they encountered each other, there was a protocol.
There isn’t a code of conduct at the moment for the South China Sea, and that is problematic because it could spark an unintended conflict.
China says the explorer and fleet admiral Zheng He (1371–1433) — whose sea adventures predate those of Christopher Columbus (1451-1506) — crossed the South China Sea during the Ming Dynasty and cites historical maps that long predate the founding of the People’s Republic in 1949.
Further, the Chinese Foreign Ministry website now states the earliest discovery of the Spratlys can be traced back 2000 years to their own Han dynasty. China maintains it has ancient claims to all of the South China Sea, despite much of it being within the exclusive economic zones of Southeast Asian neighbors.
What can anyone say or do to counter ancient arguments laying claims to territories?
Vietnam and the Philippines
Vietnam and the Philippines have both rejected the new e-passport’s China map as a basis for sharing oil, gas and fish in those waters.
Vietnam and the Philippines have officially let their displeasure be known to Beijing.
Vietnam’s Foreign Ministry states:
- “These actions by China have violated Vietnam’s sovereignty to the Paracel and Spratly islands as well as our rights and jurisdiction to related maritime areas in the South China Sea, or East Sea;”
- China should “reverse their incorrect prints” on the new e-passports; and
- “Vietnam reserves the right to carry out necessary measures suitable to Vietnamese law, international law and practices toward such passports.”
The Philippines Foreign Ministry states:
- “The Philippines strongly protests the inclusion of the nine-dash lines in the e-passport as such image covers an area that is clearly part of the Philippines’ territory and maritime domain;” and
- “The Philippines does not accept the validity of the nine-dash lines that amount to an excessive declaration of maritime space in violation of international law.”
Philippine diplomats accused China at this week’s ASEAN — Association of South-East Asian Nations — summit in Phnom Penh of using its influence over host Cambodia to push a formal statement saying that ASEAN did not want to “internationalize” the dispute.
The Philippines, which sees its alliance with the United States as a crucial check on China’s claims — especially at a time when the United States is shifting its military focus back to Asia — protested to Cambodia and has succeeded in having that clause removed from the final statement.
In Taiwan, a self-governed island that split from China after a civil war in 1949, ruling party and opposition lawmakers alike condemned the e-passport’s map. They said it could harm the warming ties the historic rivals have enjoyed since Ma Ying-jeou became President nearly five years ago.
Taiwan’s Mainland Affairs Council, the cabinet-level body responsible for ties with Beijing, stated:
“This is total ignorance of reality and only provokes disputes;” and Taipei cannot accept the map.
For India too, this is now an irritant, since it has signed agreements with the government of Vietnam to explore under-sea oil and gas deposits. China is clearly blocking this by staking territorial claim over that entire sea area.
India has responded by not just registering a strong protest with China but by also imprinting its own corrected map on visas that are issued to Chinese nationals.
China had earlier refused to give visas to visitors from Arunachal Pradesh in India and Sikkim, claiming that they were Chinese areas.
China has also started giving separate visas to visitors from the state of Jammu and Kashmir, claiming that this state is not part of India.
Curiously, the maps in China’s new e-passports do not include islands in the East China Sea that are claimed by both China and Japan.
China’s Defense of Its Claims
China’s foreign ministry stated:
- The new passport was issued based on international standards;
- “The passports’ maps with their outlines of China are not targeting a specific country;”
- “China is willing to actively communicate with the relevant countries and promote the healthy development of Sino-foreign personnel exchanges;” and
- “We hope the relevant countries can calmly treat it with rationality and restraint so that the normal visits by the Chinese and foreigners will not be unnecessarily interfered with.”
The Philippines, Brunei, Malaysia and Vietnam are scheduled to meet on December 12th to discuss claims in the South China Sea and the role of China. It remains unclear if and when China will sit down with rival claimants to draft a legally binding non-aggression pact.
For the conclusions reached by the author see the full article by the author to be found here:
Credit Featured Image: Bigstock