A Drone With No Lookout: NTSB Finds No U.S. Standards for How Uncrewed Vessels Must Be Seen or Avoid Collisions

11/19/2026
In brief

On 27 October, the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board called on the Coast Guard to set national standards for uncrewed surface vessels (USVs). The recommendation follows its investigation of a 2024 collision between a NOAA research drone and a pleasure boat on Lake Erie, gCaptain’s Mike Schuler reported. The board found that, at the time of the collision, no industry-wide standards specifically covered how USVs in U.S. inland and territorial waters must be perceptible to others, avoid collisions and navigate safely, the NTSB said.

The Collision

At about 1912 local time on 10 August 2024, a SeaTrac SP-48 operated by NOAA’s Great Lakes Environmental Research Laboratory (GLERL) collided with a privately owned 45-foot Prestige 450 Flybridge cruiser. The collision happened about six miles east-southeast of Monroe, Michigan. The drone fouled the cruiser’s starboard propeller pod, and the two vessels were towed to a marina still joined together. One minor injury was reported. The USV was a constructive total loss valued at about $186,000, and damage to the cruiser was estimated at $100,000, according to NTSB Marine Investigation Report 26-32.

The 15.7-foot drone was in “adapted hold” mode: it automatically returned to preset waypoints whenever it drifted outside a 150-foot radius. A remote pilot monitored it passively from shore. Only about a foot of hull showed above the water. The NTSB judged it unlikely to appear on the radar or AIS that recreational boats in the area typically carry, and it had no audible warning, gCaptain reported. The drone itself could not assess nearby traffic. “The USV could not calculate decisions regarding navigation or operational action and thus could not take appropriate action to avoid a collision,” the board said.

Other coverage of the report adds detail:

  • Baird Maritime reports that the drone carried no radar reflector and its cameras were switched off. GLERL staff learned of the collision only when the Coast Guard called more than 30 minutes later.
  • The Maritime Executive notes that the pilot was working from his home. It also reports that the cruiser was running without AIS, radar or chart plotter switched on, which was fully compliant for a boat of its size. In three-foot waves an hour before sunset, its operator had little chance of seeing the drone.

Probable Cause and Recommendations

The NTSB set the probable cause as the USV’s inadequate perceptibility to nearby vessels, given the operating area and conditions. It added “the lack of active monitoring given the vessel’s configuration, mode of operation, and level of autonomy, which left the USV without a proper lookout,” the report states.

The board issued six recommendations, according to the NTSB:

  • Coast Guard: develop and issue a national framework of perceptibility, collision-avoidance and navigational-safety standards for USVs, and write those standards into regulation.
  • NOAA: revise its policies so its USVs are perceptible, and test that each vessel can be detected by the operators of boats typically found where it works. NOAA should also require monitoring that matches each USV’s actual level of autonomy, operating area and mode of operation.
  • SeaTrac Systems: modify the SP-48’s design to make it more perceptible.

Why It Matters 

The finding that matters most is conceptual. The board applied a lookout standard, a duty as old as the collision regulations themselves. In its view, the drone met it neither on board nor from shore: it had no ability of its own to see and avoid, and no active human watch. Autonomy does not remove the lookout duty. It moves that duty somewhere else, and an operator has to show where it went.

The case also shows a burden that falls unevenly. The recreational boat was legally equipped and still had little chance of seeing the drone. As small, low-signature USVs spread through busy coastal and inland waters for science, survey and defence work, the burden of being seen will have to rest on the uncrewed vessel and its operator. Recreational mariners cannot be expected to adapt to it.

For military users, the same features that make small USVs useful — low freeboard, low signature, long unattended loiter — make them hazardous among civilian traffic. That holds in training areas and in home waters. A Coast Guard framework built from a NOAA research incident could end up shaping the rules under which naval and commercial drone fleets test and operate in U.S. waters. The recommendation is a first step: the NTSB recommends, and the Coast Guard decides whether and how to regulate.