The Perspective of the Chief of Staff of the Indian Air Force: Shaping a Way Ahead

08/15/2018

By Air Marshal VK Jimmy Bhatia (Retd)

Chief of the Air Staff, Air Chief Marshal BS Dhanoa, has confirmed that IAF has received bids from six global vendors in response to IAF’s Request for Information (RFI) for 110 modern combat jets, and that the induction of 36 Rafale jets already contracted from France would begin from September next year.

The procurement process would be progressed under the provisions of Defence Procurement Procedure (DPP) 2016, and that “IAF intends to induct 15 per cent of the aircraft in a direct fly away condition which would facilitate a relatively faster induction till the time production is commenced by the (Indian) Strategic Partner.”

In an interview with India Strategic on the eve of the Farnborough Airshow, Air Chief Marshal Dhanoa observed that as the guardian of the Indian skies, IAF was ready to face any situation, 24 x 7, any time.

Asked about the drawdown in the strength of IAF Fighter Squadrons, he said IAF is giving “due emphasis” to this aspect and that the existing aircraft in its inventory, the MiG-29, Jaguar and Mirage 2000, are being upgraded while a number of indigenous HAL-made Light Combat Aircraft (LCA) Tejas are also planned to be inducted. Besides the 40 Tejas already ordered, IAF has asked for 83 Tejas Mk 1A, which would have AESA radar and BVR missile capability.

He also said that the order for 272 Su-30 MKI aircraft, or 13 Squadrons, being supplied by HAL would be over by 2021. (Most of the aircraft have already been received).

Here is the full text of the Interview:

India Strategic.

To begin with, heartiest congratulations for a very well conducted Pan-India air exercise Gagan Shakti 2018. The entire country has acknowledged the prowess of air power and the IAF should be rightly proud of what was achieved during the exercise. Could you please comment on what were the major takeaways of Gagan Shakti 2018 and if there would be any follow ups?

Air Chief.

Ex Gagan Shakti provided extremely valuable takeaways. It validated the capability to conduct sustained high tempo operations. This in turn validated our internal manpower and process optimisation. Joint operations took centre stage in the exercise. Our sister services provided exceptional support and we were able to refine various joint operation concepts.

As you are aware, the IAF’s airlift and heli-lift capabilities have been vastly expanded in recent years with the induction of C-17s, C-130Js and a large number of Mi-17 V5 Medium Lift helicopters. This entire capability was exercised and used to validate our ability to move forces on strategic and tactical levels.

It also brought home valuable lessons for combat support, which was rendered in an exceptional manner by various DPSUs and OEMs. This enabled the IAF to maintain and sustain extremely high rates of serviceability throughout the exercise period, and produce an unprecedented quantum of flying. The intense flying activity over extended periods also allowed the IAF to exercise its networked AD system. The system has now been extended in coverage and fine tuned and optimised.

India Strategic.

How is the IAF planning to cope up with the increasing drawdown in its combat squadrons’ strength?

Air Chief.

The IAF sees itself as the guardian of the Indian skies and the first responder in all contingencies. We are therefore 24 x 7 ready to face any situation with our available resources. As far as the drawdown in the strength of fighter squadrons is concerned, it is being given due emphasis.

We are upgrading MiG-29, Jaguar and Mirage-2000 aircraft in a phased manner as a part of obsolescence management so that they remain relevant and contemporary.

Induction of 36 x Rafale aircraft will commence by September 2019 and will significantly enhance our operational capability.

Induction of the balance of 272 x Su-30 MKI aircraft from HAL is under process and will be completed by 2021. The induction of the 40 indigenous LCA is also ongoing.

Additionally, the RFP for procurement of 83 x LCA Mk 1A has been issued in December 2017. The Government of India plans to procure fighter aircraft under the ‘Make in India’ initiative for which RFI has been issued on April 6, 2018, and is also examining other suitable options.

Future inductions will include the LCA Mk-II, which is expected to form a bulk of the Air Force in the years to come, as the IAF proposes to replace its Mirage-2000, MiG-29 and Jaguar with this aircraft.

The IAF is also supporting DRDO in the D&D of indigenous Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA). If all the inductions take place as planned, the IAF is expected to achieve its authorised strength of fighter squadrons by 2040.

India Strategic.

When the IAF receives its full complement of the total order of 272 Su-30 MKI Jet fighters, would it have received its fair share of ‘Heavy’ fighters or would it consider additional acquisitions of these aircraft which are reportedly on offer from the Russian OEM?

In the same context, has the IAF worked out an optimum mix of the Heavy/ Medium/Light jet fighters for a balanced fleet of its fighter force? Please elucidate.

Air Chief.

The IAF seeks capabilities which are required to maintain its combat preparedness and operational edge over potential adversaries.

In that regard, once the deliveries of the license manufactured Su-30 MKI are complete, which is expected by 2021, the IAF will have 13 Squadrons of the Su-30 MKI.

As far as additional procurement is concerned, an RFI for 110 fighter aircraft has been hosted by the IAF to meet its operational requirements under Strategic Partnership route.

India Strategic. How does the IAF plan to steer the new Fighter ‘RFI’ to make good the time it lost due to MoD abandoning the earlier so-called single-engine fighter programme?

Air Chief. The RFI for 110 fighter aircraft was hosted on April 6, 2018 and six vendors responded to the RFI. The procurement process would be progressed under the provisions of DPP 2016.

The IAF intends to induct 15 percent of the aircraft in a direct fly away condition which would facilitate a relatively faster induction till the time production is commenced by the Strategic Partner.

India Strategic.

We heard that IAF was quite satisfied with the ‘Tejas’ performance during Gagan Shakti 2018, including the ‘Surge’ phase.

Your comments please.

Also, how is the Tejas induction programme unfolding and what is the latest on the Mk-IA version? Will the IAF be able to get the Op capabilities it is looking for in the Mk 1A? And, most importantly will it get the new version on time?

Air Chief.

LCA is a versatile platform and its efficacy in various roles has been validated during Ex-Gagan Shakti. Tejas is a potent platform in ground attack as well as air defence role. Performance of the aircraft in air-to-ground weapon delivery was observed to be exceptional.

For air defence role, aircraft has good AI radar capability and integration of BVR missile is in the final stage. With active support of HAL the aircraft was found to be highly reliable during conduct of surge ops.

The commissioning of the first Squadron of LCA Tejas in July 2016 marks a significant step towards indigenous capability building. Currently, the squadron has nine aircraft and we expect the squadron to be fully equipped by March 2019.

The LCA Final Operational Clearance (FOC) contract of 2010 seeks Air-to-Air Refuelling, Operational Data Link (ODL) and better weapons. The FOC is expected in 2019. As far as the LCA Mk 1A is concerned, the first flight is expected by 2020.

The LCA Mk 1A apart from addressing obsolescence issues and maintainability improvements will have additional capabilities such as Active Electronically Scanned Array (AESA) radar, Beyond Visual Range (BVR) missiles, Air-to-Air Refuelling (AAR) capability, Electronic Warfare (EW) suite and advanced avionics.

We are hopeful that ADA and HAL will ensure that the LCA Mk 1A is delivered to IAF on time.

India Strategic.

AD Weapons: The indigenous Akash SAM System reportedly worked well during the Gagan Shakti Exercise and is shaping up well. Will the IAF be inducting more of these systems? In this context, what is the latest on the Israeli Spyder systems which were expected to join operational service in the IAF and the Indo-Israeli joint venture of MR-SAM? Also, what is the latest on acquisition of S-400 Triumf systems from Russia?

Air Chief.

Akash Missile System performed well during exercise Gagan Shakti. A case has been initiated to procure seven more squadrons of Akash Missile Systems (AMS) from BEL. The first Squadron of SPYDER missile was raised on February 16, 2018. Delivery of equipment for the other three squadrons is under way.

The system was also successfully utilised during Exercise Gagan Shakti. The MRSAM programme involves joint development and delivery of Firing Units (FUs) by DRDO in collaboration with Israel Aerospace Industry (IAI), Israel.

The contract for joint development and supply of MRSAM was signed between DRDO and IAI, Israel on February 16, 2009. There has been delay in inducting the system, while the first MRSAM Squadron has already been resurrected in 2015, the equipment should be delivered in 2019.

The S-400 is in use by the Russian Armed Forces since the year 2007. It is a long range anti aircraft missile system capable of intercepting Ballistic missile and low RCS targets like UAVs and cruise missiles. This system would be a game changer in our context and would provide us the much needed layered Air Defence at long ranges. The acquisition process for the system is under way.

India Strategic.

IAF is reportedly in the process of revamping its AD surveillance systems with DAC having cleared acquisition of High Powered Radars. How is IAF moving forward in terms of modernising its entire inventory of high, medium and LL Radars? Your comments please.

Air Chief.

The AD framework of the IAF is indeed being revamped. This is on two counts namely, induction of new state-of-the-art systems, and their integration into a completely networked AD system. As far as the induction of new systems is concerned, the process is proceeding smoothly.

There has been a concerted effort to induct cutting edge technology & follow up with indigenous manufacture. The Medium Powered Radar (MPR), Low Level Transportable Radar (LLTR), Low Level Lightweight Radar (LLLWR) categories have all seen infusion of large numbers of indigenously developed and produced radars.

This has increased the sensor density manifold in all sectors, including the mountainous regions in the North and East. Acquisition of HPRs, Aerostats and mountain radars will further reinforce this.

The integration of these increased numbers of systems into a highly automated system was undertaken indigenously with BEL being the lead agency. I am happy to state that the system was tested extensively in the exercise and proved itself as a robust force multiplier. IAF has graduated from a point defence, to area defence and is now moving towards layered defence.

India Strategic.

Did the IAF feel the inadequacy in terms of sheer numbers where its vital force multipliers such as AWACS and Mid-air refuellers are concerned during the recent Pan-India Exercise? If, so what actions are being initiated by the IAF to augment their numbers?

Air Chief.

The deployment of AWACS during the exercise was as per the exercise setting. To overcome the inadequacy, one DRDO developed AEW&C aircraft on Embraer platform has been inducted and the second aircraft is likely to be developed in FoC configuration by the end of 2018.

The procurement case for two additional IL-76 based AWACS is presently with MoD and is at CFA approval stage. Indigenous AWACS (I) programme for up to six aircraft is being progressed by DRDO. As an immediate measure, to meet the urgent operational requirements, IAF is also exploring latest technology aircraft available globally which are operational and in use.

India Strategic.

What is the score on acquisition of armed UAV systems or UCAVs the IAF was reportedly working on? In the same context, how is the indigenous UCAV programme developing?

Air Chief.

The IAF is progressing the case of upgrading the existing UAV fleet. Also, the Medium Altitude Low Endurance (MALE) RPA TAPAS (earlier called Rustom-II) is being developed by DRDO. The platform is to be developed as a weaponised platform. The IAF is seeking UAVs with stealth features which can enter contested airspace. IAF is exploring various options.

India Strategic.

When is the first woman fighter likely to be declared fully Ops to become a full-fledged member of the fighter fraternity in the IAF?

Air Chief.

Two women fighter pilots are presently progressing through their Conversion Syllabus on Bison aircraft. Both have successfully carried out their solo flight. They are likely to complete their Day Ops Syllabus by end of the year and be Fully Ops by March 2019.

India Strategic.

And lastly for the short questionnaire, would you like to share some thoughts on your latest Brazil visit?

Air Chief.

The key objectives of the visit were to explore avenues of mutual exchange of operational experience and share ideas to enhance individual capabilities. It was interesting to know that Brazilian Air Force drives the aviation related research in Brazil. This allows for focussed monitoring of projects, programmes, timelines and technological interface. The trip was a success so far as all objectives go.

This article was published by our partner India Strategic and republished with their permission.

http://www.indiastrategic.in/2018/07/11/six-vendors-respond-to-iaf-rfi-for-110-combat-jets-says-air-chief-marshal-dhanoa/

The featured photo shows Chief of the Air Staff Air Chief Marshal BS Dhanoa going for a sortie in a Rafale fighter during his visit to France in July 2017.

 

US Working with India and Australia on P-8 Operations

08/13/2018

By the end of RIMPAC, the U.S. and Indian planes were sharing high-end missions, an Australian P-8A squadron joined in as a major step towards the Royal Australian Navy declaring final operational capability on their new planes, and the U.S. and Australian P-8s not only prosecuted submarines but also dropped Harpoon missiles on a decommissioned U.S. ship during a sinking exercise(SINKEX).

Commander of Submarine Force for U.S. Pacific Fleet Rear Adm. Daryl Caudle told USNI News during a July 25 interview at Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam that the aircraft play an important role in managing the entire theater anti-submarine warfare picture.

“One of my main objectives is building a more lethal anti-submarine enterprise. So lethality is a theme that stems down from our secretary of defense and the National Defense Strategy, down through the Pacific Fleet commander, all the way down to me as the submarine force commander.

“And to build lethality, you have to have capabilities, you gotta have highly trained people, and speed is important. Submarines move around at a certain speed, but airplanes move around at a much faster speed,” he said.

“So when we detect adversary submarines, to be able to employ aircraft onto that contact information just greatly enhances the legs, the speed and the lethality that we can employ against that. So the P-8 adds an entirely new dimension for us to be able to do that mission and is just an incredible capable aircraft. The mission space greatly enhanced over the P-3. … The information system’s greatly enhanced….”

The above was taken from an article by Megan Eckstein published by USNI news on August 10, 2018.

The rest of the article can be read here:

https://news.usni.org/2018/08/10/video-navy-p-8as-use-rimpac-to-collaborate-with-indian-navy-practice-in-high-traffic-environment?utm_source=USNI+News&utm_campaign=f5d920eb05-USNI_NEWS_DAILY&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_0dd4a1450b-f5d920eb05-230422265&mc_cid=f5d920eb05&mc_eid=d5b4bb05ef

Recently, Second Line of Defense visited RAAF Edinbourgh and talked with Commander of the P-8/Triton force in the RAAF.

That interview will appear soon.

The Coming of the A320neo Multi-Mission Aircraft

Airbus Defence and Space is shaping a template for integrated air operations, which they call the Future Combat Air Systems.

Within this template, each key air combat platform is being reshaped or designed from the ground up to provide a contribution to integrated air operations.

A platform which makes sense both from its role in the commercial portfolio as well as for the demand side for military forces, namely, the A320 neo.

The A320 platform is widely operated worldwide and provides a solid platform from which to build a multi-mission ISR or C2 aircraft for missions such as those associated with maritime patrol aircraft.

If Airbus designed this aircraft from the ground up with considerations for new technologies with regard to upgradeability and interoperability, they have a chance to shape a new offerring for a 21st century air force.


In the IISS wrap up of the Farnbourgh Air Show in their Defence Analysis Briefing, the emergence of an A320 neo multi-mission platform was discussed.

“Airbus is looking to improve its offering too, saying that the A320 neo was being considered for new applications and that the “A320 M” A — would be designed to fulfill a range of ISR roles, particularly maritime patrol and anti-submarine warfare.”

Clearly, Germany and France could provide a launch customer and the Canadians are clearly looking as well towards a CP-140 and could well become part of a launch customer base.

Notably, with Airbus relationship on the C series, a broader relationship between Airbus and Canada is clearly possible.

Airbus Defence and Space has described their approach as follows with the title “Airbus evaluates an A320neo multi-mission version:”

The best-selling jetliner is considered for a wide range of ISR and transport operations

Having made its mark in the commercial airline sector, the A320neo is now being considered by Airbus for new applications: as a highly-capable and cost-effective platform for ISR (intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance) duties and as a military transport.

The variant – designated A320M3A – would be designed to fulfill a range of ISR roles, particularly maritime patrol and anti-submarine warfare. It also can be outfitted with modular roll-on/roll-off payloads for airlift missions ranging from carrying passengers, troops and VIPs to medical evacuation (medevac) and transporting cargo.

Airbus’ consideration of the A320M3A is in response to market demand, spurred by the growing use of more capable ISR systems – which require physically larger host platforms with increased electrical power and more efficient cooling systems than previously were the case for C4ISR aircraft.

A proven, low-risk solution

One of the biggest applications of the A320M3A is for maritime patrol and anti-submarine warfare, with countries in Europe and elsewhere seeking replacements for ageing aircraft – many of which will be encouraged to develop fleet commonality driven by the intensive growth of joint operations with member nations of NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization).

Advantages in offering the new engine option (NEO) version of Airbus’ A320 commercial jetliner include an extensive capability for growth in a fuselage cross-section that is wider than its competitor in the same size category, the long range and endurance, as well as the lowest operational and life-cycle costs in its class. Other pluses for the A320M3A are the aircraft’s high reliability (proven in airline service), and the resources of an established worldwide supply chain and training network.

The A320M3A also benefits from being a low-risk solution: being based on Airbus’ highly-mature A320 airliner family in high-rate production; and building on the company’s proven capabilities in producing military derivatives of its commercial aircraft – such as the A330 Multi-Role Tanker Transport (MRTT), which is in use by military services around the globe.

 

 

 

Modernizing the Egyptian Fleet: Adding the Meko Frigate?

By defenceWeb

Egypt is considering purchasing two Meko A200 frigates from Germany’s ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS) as discussions with France’s Naval Group on the acquisition of further Gowind corvettes grinds to a halt over cost concerns.

France’s La Tribune late last month reported that the German deal would be worth around 1 billion euros.

TKMS urgently needs additional sales after losing out on the German KS-180 vessel programme, which is worth some 3.5 billion euros.

La Tribune reports that the German government is offering attractive credit through financial company Euler Hermes, whereas the Naval Group is struggling with its credit offers.

Egypt will presumably opt for the Aster 30 missile manufactured by MBDA, but apparently France will only sell this if it is used on Italian or French vessels, so Egypt would then be forced to make user of an alternative like the Umkhonto, as Algeria did.

In 2014 Egypt ordered four Gowind 2500 corvettes for around 1 billion euros, with one, El Fateh (971) built in Lorient and the other three being built in Egypt. El Fateh was delivered to Egypt in October 2017. The contract made provision for an option for two more.

First published by defenceWeb, Monday on 13 August 2018 and republished with their permission.

http://www.defenceweb.co.za/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=52733:egypt-looking-at-acquiring-meko-frigates-from-germany&catid=51:Sea&Itemid=106

 

 

The SCALP Missile for Egypt: The ITAR Barrier

08/11/2018

By defenceWeb

France is looking for a way around the United States’ blocking of Scalp cruise missile technology for Egypt, and is exploring the possibility of replacing American components with alternatives so it can deliver the missiles as well as additional Rafale fighters to Egypt.

French Defence Minister Florence Parly recently said in the country’s National Assembly that the decision by the United States to use the International Trade in Arms Regulation (ITAR) agreement to block the sale of Scalp missiles to Egypt could be circumvented if domestically-built parts are used instead.

“In this case, we will not be able to lift the US opposition to the sale of Scalp missiles.

“The only thing we can do is for MBDA [which makes the missiles] to make some investment in research and development to be able to manufacture similar components that are not covered by ITAR,” Parly said last month.

“We can do it for the Egyptian Scalp/Rafale in so far as the new missile can be built with a reasonable delay, though the customer might find this delay a bit too long.”

“It is true that we depend on this [US International Traffic in Arms Regulations] mechanism: We are at the mercy of the Americans when our equipment is concerned,” she said. Because the United States will not lift its opposition to the sale of Scalp missiles, France has had to come up with alternatives.

Egypt has ordered 24 Rafale jets from France, and is looking to acquire 12 more, but only if it can buy Scalp missiles for them.

It appears earlier reports that the impasse with the United States had been resolved, were premature.

La Tribune reported that French President Emmanual Macron broached the Scalp issue during his visit to the United States in April.

The newspaper in July reported that licenses had been granted to export components used in the missiles to Egypt while France is also in the process of finding alternative components for the missile that are ITAR-free.

In February it emerged that a plan to acquire 12 Rafales stalled after the United States refused to sell the manufacturer key components of the SCALP missile.

The planned Egyptian acquisition of 12 Rafale fighter aircraft has been in the making since November 2017. It was billed to be a follow-up sale to a February 2015 agreement for an Egyptian acquisition of 24 Rafale fighter jets.

The new Egyptian defence minister Mohamed Ahmed Zaki Mohamed visited France in July, with Egypt expressing interest in acquiring 30 Patroller unmanned aerial vehicles and Cougar helicopters for the navy. Egypt was also interested in acquiring two additional Gowind corvettes but apparently negotiations are stalled over pricing and is now looking at German warships.

Forecast International notes that the deepening Egyptian-French relationship comes as the volume of U.S. sales to Egypt has waned after the US put a temporary hold on military sales and assistance to Egypt.

Since President Sisi took office, Egypt has turned to Russia and France for the big force modernization contracts. From Russia, Egypt purchased dozens of MiG-29M/M2 fighter jets and Ka-52 attack helicopters.

The Egyptian military introduced Antey-2500 surface-to-air missile systems into service and is to procure T-90S/SK main battle tanks.

France has sold Mistral helicopter carriers (initially destined for Russia) to Egypt, along with a FREMM frigate, several Gowind 2500 corvettes, and Rafale fighter jets. Further contracts with both countries are planned.

Reprinted with the permission of defenceWeb.

First published by defenceWeb on August 7, 2018.

http://www.defenceweb.co.za/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=52683:france-looking-to-circumvent-us-components-in-scalp-missile&catid=35:Aerospace&Itemid=107

 

UAV Market Growing: Projected $25 Billion by 2023

by defenceWeb

The global market for unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), or drones, is anticipated to reach $25 billion by the end of 2023, witnessing a compound annual growth rate of 18.2% over the forecast period owing to the significant use of drones in various sectors.

This is according to a new report published by Research Nester on 6 August.

It said that the military drones segment is anticipated to garner largest market share in terms of revenue over the forecast period which can be attributed to their widespread functions in law and enforcement sector combined with military applications by various countries around the globe to safeguard their borders among other applications.

These factors are anticipated to drive the overall drone market by noteworthy revenue by the end of forecast period.

The global market for drones is anticipated to reach $25 billion by the end of 2023 witnessing a compound annual growth rate of 18.2% over the forecast period owing to the significant use of drones in various sectors. In terms of volume, there was sale of nearly 4 million commercial drones in 2015 which is further expected to expand with 18 million a year by the end of 2023.

Factors such as wide range of drone applications in numerous sectors such as weather monitoring, traffic monitoring among others are estimated to drive the demand for drones over the forecast period.

Further, the rise in emerging market of drones is motivating various universities to offer bachelor degree in Unmanned Systems Applications which is anticipated to encourage the growth of drone market over the forecast period.

In the regional segment, North America is anticipated to dominate the overall drone market during the forecast period. This can be attributed to wide scale applications and production of drones in commercial sector.

Further, Europe is anticipated to grow with attractive market share in drone market over the forecast period.

Wide Scale Applications to Grow the Market

The growth of the drone market is driven by its wide scale applications in search & rescue operations, drone-based photography, pest detection in agriculture sector, rescue of mammal species and various monitoring applications such as weather monitoring, pollution monitoring and volcanic monitoring among others.

These applications are believed to benefit the expansion of drone market in upcoming years.

However, stringent government regulations regarding violation of privacy are estimated to hamper the growth of drone market in near future.

Republished with permission of our partner defenceWeb.

First published by defenceWeb, Wednesday, 08 August 2018

http://www.defenceweb.co.za/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=52699:uav-market-to-reach-25-billion-by-2023&catid=125:unmanned-aerial-vehicles&Itemid=306

 

 

 

Visiting HMAS Hobart: A Key Building Block in the Remaking of the Royal Australian Navy

08/06/2018

By Robbin Laird

During my current trip to Australia, I started with the opportunity to visit the HMAS Hobart, the first Aegis Air Warfare destroyer for the Royal Australian Navy.

This was my second visit to Garden Island, and it is always exciting to see the city of Sydney in the backdrop to a major Australian naval base as the arrival of the First Fleet seems not so distant when you are not far from where they landed in 1788.

The HMAS Hobart is the first of the three Aegis Air Warfare destroyers to be operational with the Navy and the second ship will be commissioned later this year.

The ship introduces a new level of combat capability into the Royal Australian Navy in which the ship’s reach is significantly greater than any previous ship operational in the Aussie fleet because of its Aegis Combat system.

It is a key building block in shaping an integrated air-sea task force navy in that the capabilities onboard the ship can contribute to an integrated C2, ISR and strike grid in which the evolving capabilities of the ADF can cover a wider area of operation in the waters surrounding Australia or in service of missions further abroad.

As Rear Admiral Mayer noted during an interview I conducted with him while he was Commander of the Australian fleet:

“We are joint by necessity.

“Unlike the US Navy, we do not have our own air force or our own army. Joint is not a theological choice, it’s an operational necessity.”

What clearly this means is that the future of the Hobart class is working ways to operate in an integrated battlespace with land-based RAAF F-35s, Tritons and P-8s among other air assets.

Their future is not protecting the carrier battle group, as the Aussies have no carrier.

Rather, their future is “to provide air defence for accompanying ships in addition to land forces and infrastructure in coastal areas, and for self-protection against missiles and aircraft.”

The skill sets being learned to operate the ship, notably the workflow on board the ship, in terms of the use of data, ISR and C2 systems, working situational awareness throughout the work stations onboard the ship, are foundational for other ships coming to the fleet.

With the coming of the Brisbane, the HMAS Hobart will no longer be a single ship but the lead into a class of ships.

And with the Australian decision with regard to its new frigates which will leverage the Aegis combat system capability as well, the HMAS Hobart has become the lead into a whole new approach to how the Australian fleet will shape its combat networks as well.

Building a New Australian Frigate: The Next Step in Building a New National Shipbuilding Enterprise

This means that the training and support provided to HMAS Hobart is a foundation for a larger effort for the Navy as well.

And with the addition of F-35 as well as P-8s and Tritons as well as the evolution of the KC-30A tanker, the fleet looks to become a core element for an integrated air-maritime task force approach.

Building a 21st Century Australian Navy

Indeed, when visiting HMAS Hobart one can already see crew from the Brisbane onboard getting ready for its initial deployments as well.

The Aegis combat system pioneered by the US Navy and Lockheed Martin has become a global capability as an Aegis Global Enterprise has emerged in which new types of ships have been built carrying variants of the Aegis combat system.

This started with the Japanese becoming the first foreign navy to buy Aegis and then in a critical breakthrough moment, Aegis was sold to the Spanish Navy which built a new type of ship on which to operate Aegis.

I was working for a consulting company supporting the Navy at the time, and was supporting what would become what I coined in the mid-1990s, the Aegis Global Enterprise.

There was opposition both within the US Navy and without to selling Aegis to the Spanish Navy but senior leaders at the time in the Clinton Administration, notably Secretary of Defense Perry, supported the effort.

Working on the issue at the time, I learned a great deal about how a good decision can navigate critics and challenges, and fortunately for the Navy the decision was taken to sell the Aegis combat system to the Spanish.

Much like the F-35 global enterprise, the benefits to allies and the US alike become obvious with the cross-learning and not just from the US to the allies, but among allies as well as from allies to the United States.

The HMAS Hobart is clearly a result of this process.

It is a variant of the Spanish ship and was sold via Spain to Australia.

The senior staff and crew operated on a Spanish frigate last year to get used to the form factor of the ship and could anticipate the workflow as well prior to getting their own ship.

According to an article published last year by the Royal Australian Navy, the time spent onboard the Spanish ship was highlighted.

Captain Stavridis said he and some of his crew members were fortunate to have spent time at sea in their Spanish sister ship, Cristobal Colon (F105), earlier this year.

“The time spent in Cristobal Colon was extremely valuable as it provided a unique opportunity to better understand the platform and to work with a crew that have a detailed working knowledge of the ship,” Captain Stavridis said.

“Cristobal Colon’s crew were extremely generous in their time and ensured that we were given all opportunities to learn as much as we could.”

He said the layout of Cristobal Colon was very similar to the Hobart class.

“In fact the Hobart class was based on the F104 design with modifications taken from the F105.”

(For a look at the Cristobal Colon, see the following:

https://foronaval.com/2018/02/23/visitamos-la-fragata-cristobal-colon-f-105/)

Of course, the US Navy has been working with HMAS Hobart and indeed the ship will leave soon for San Diego for further collaborative efforts.

And as one US Navy officer put it: “We expect to learn a great deal from you as you shape the operations of the Hobart as it is integrated into the Australian fleet.”

This is the key advantage of a global enterprise approach.

We projected that this would be the case if their was the sale to Spain of Aegis.

Now one can walk onboard the reality, namely, the HMAS Hobart.

Appendix: The Air Warfare Destroyer Alliance

The Hobart class is being built by the Air Warfare Destroyer Alliance.

The AWDs are being built for Australia’s specific defence needs and will provide a significant increase in Australia’s defence capabilities.

The AWDs will provide greater protection for ADF personnel by providing air defence for accompanying ships as well as land forces and infrastructure on nearby coastal areas. The AWDs will also provide self-protection against attacking missiles and aircraft.

The Aegis Weapon System incorporating the state-of-the-art phased array radar, AN/ SPY 1D(V), in combination with the SM-2 missile, will provide an advanced air defence system capable of engaging enemy aircraft and missiles at ranges in excess of 150 kilometres.

The AWDs will also carry a MH-60R Seahawk ‘Romeo’ naval combat helicopter for surveillance and response to support key warfare areas. The surface warfare function will include long range anti-ship missiles and a naval gun capable of firing extended range munitions in support of land forces. The AWDs will also be able to conduct Undersea Warfare and will be equipped with modern sonar systems, decoys and surface-launched torpedoes.

Coupled with an array of close-in defensive weapons, all of these capabilities ensure the AWDs have the layered defensive and offensive resources required to win the battle against 21st century conventional and asymmetric threats.

The Defence team is led by the AWD Program Office in the Defence Materiel Organisation (DMO), which retains overall responsibility for the project management and delivery of the three Air Warfare Destroyers. The DMO, through the Minister for Defence, is responsible to the people of Australia to ensure that the future AWDs are delivered to the RAN on time, on budget and to the required capability.

In April 2005 the Australian Government selected Raytheon Australia Pty Ltd as the Combat System – Systems Engineer, and in May 2005 selected ASC AWD Shipbuilder Pty Ltd as the Shipbuilder. ASC and Raytheon Australia join the DMO in forming the AWD Alliance which is now working hard to deliver this cutting edge capability to the Navy.

On 20 June 2007, the Australian Government announced that the Navantia designed F100 had been selected as the basis for Australia’s future Hobart Class AWDs. The F100 ensures tomorrow’s Navy has the best equipment to defend Australia and its national interests.

Australia’s new Air Warfare Destroyers will be named HMAS Hobart, HMAS Brisbane and HMAS Sydney ensuring the three ships reflect a rich history of service.

When the AWDs are delivered to the Royal Australian Navy they will be in service, defending and supporting Australian interests, for more than 30 years. To put this timeframe into perspective, some of the men and women who will serve on the AWDs are not yet born.

https://www.ausawd.com/content.aspx?p=62

Characteristics of the Hobart Class Destroyers

The Hobart Class Air Warfare Destroyer (AWD) will be one of the world’s most capable multi-purpose warships.

In selecting the Navantia-designed F100 as the baseline platform design and coupling it with the Aegis Weapon System, the Australian Government has ensured tomorrow’s Navy has the best equipment to defend Australia and its national interests.

Since entering service with the Spanish Armada, F100s have worked alongside US forces in the Persian Gulf as the first foreign Aegis equipped ships to be fully integrated into a US Navy Carrier Strike Group and have successfully been deployed as the flagship of NATO’s Maritime Group Standing Reaction Force.

The Hobart Class AWDs, which are under constructionat three shipyards in Newcastle (NSW), Williamstown (Victoria) and Osborne (South Australia) will provide air defence for accompanying ships in addition to land forces and infrastructure in coastal areas, and for self-protection against missiles and aircraft.

They will be capable across the full spectrum of joint maritime operations, from area air defence and escort duties, right through to peacetime national tasking and diplomatic missions.

The AWDs’ Hobart Class Combat System, built around the Aegis Weapon System incorporating the state-of-the-art phased array radar, AN/ SPY 1D(V), will provide an advanced air defence system capable of engaging enemy aircraft and missiles at ranges in excess of 150 kilometres.

The AWDs will carry a helicopter for surveillance and response to support key warfare areas. The surface warfare function will include long range anti-ship missiles and a naval gun capable of firing extended range munitions in support of land forces.

They will also be able to conduct Undersea Warfare and will be equipped with modern sonar systems, decoys, surface-launched torpedoes and an array of effective close-in defensive weapons. These capabilities will ensure the AWDs have the layered defensive and offensive resources required to counter conventional and asymmetric threats.

The Hobart Class Combat System will be amongst the most advanced maritime warfare capabilities available and ensure the RAN has unprecedented levels of interoperability with Australia’s allies.

When Australia’s AWDs enter service in the next decade, they’ll be part of a fleet of around 100 Aegis equipped ships operating across the globe and will spearhead a quantum leap in the RAN’s air warfare capability.

https://www.ausawd.com/content.aspx?p=63

The Hobart Class – Differences from the F100 Class

Navantia’s F104 ship design is the basis for the AWD. The F104 baseline is being updated for AWD to include;

Key F105 features,Australian Combat system modifications, and Selected platform upgrades that are unique to the Hobart Class.

These features are summarised as follows:

F105 Modifications

  • More efficient and powerful diesel engines coupled with improved fuel tank arrangements will provide increased range,
  • The inclusion of a bow thruster will improve manoeuvrability in harbours;
  • Improvements to underway replenishment arrangements for manpower efficiencies;
  • Changes to funnel tops to improve the ship’s air wake; and
  • Bunk size increases to improve habitability.

AWD Combat System Modifications

  • The Hobart Class will use the Aegis Weapon System Baseline 7.1and the AN/SPY-1D(V) Phased Array Radar.
  • The Under Sea Warfare capability will be upgraded by:
  • Enhanced Anti Submarine Warfare capabilities and the addition of a torpedo defence system;
  • ASW decoys for torpedo defence;
  • Enhanced undersea communications;
  • Integration of the MU90 torpedo

Other changes include:

  • Modification of the MK45 gun and Gun Fire Control System, including provision for Extended Range Munitions (ERM);
  • Addition of the Cooperative Engagement Capability (CEC);
  • Modification of the IFF UPX-29 to the current tactical standard;
  • Addition of an Horizon Search Radar (HSR) for improved anti-ship missile defence;
  • Upgrades to the Surface-to-Surface Missile System to improve target selectivity in congested water, littoral and coastal operations;
  • Upgrades to the Very Short Range Defence system to improve its integration and utility against asymmetric surface threats;
  • Upgrades to the Electronic Warfare system, including the addition of electronic attack capabilities;
  • Addition of X/Ka Satcom and INMARSAT Fleet Broadband and INMARSAT C capability;
  • Improved Infrared Search and Track capabilities;
  • Improved Electro-Optical Surveillance capability;
  • Addition of Nulka Launchers for active missile decoys;

AWD-Unique Platform Modifications

  • The ship’s displacement will be increased to 7,000 tonnes for an improved service life margin.
  • Cold weather operation will be improved to allow for deployment into Australia’s southern waters.
  • The hangar will be modified to accommodate a range of helicopters.
  • Other modifications include:
  • Increased total cold room capacity for improved endurance;
  • Incorporation of a fixed gas detection system to warn of the presence of harmful gases in compartments where personnel exposure risks exist;
  • Modification of the 220V/50Hz network to 240V/50 Hz, incorporation of Residual Current Devices (RCD) and the Australian pin configuration for general purpose outlets, and
  • Modification of existing stowage, and increases in the overall number of stowage facilities, for thermal protective suit and life raft containers.

https://www.ausawd.com/content.aspx?p=97

The slideshow above shows HMAS Hobart and the photos are credited to the Australian Department of Defence.

The videos below provide further looks at the new ship and its capabilities.

Working Manned-Unmanned Teaming

By Todd Miller

In what seems like a sci-fi movie of only a few years ago, “artificial intelligence empowered, war fighting drones” teamed with manned command and control are shaping up as the path forward. The last few years have seen several manned-unmanned teaming (MUM-T) initiatives by the USAF and private industry.

On July 30, 2018 Textron Aviation Defense, LLC announced that they had demonstrated MUM-T capability on the Scorpion Jetwith Textron Systems’ “Synturian®” control and collaboration technology(official Textron Press release here).

MUM-T has been discussed by for several years and we are now starting to see the progress.  The assessment of “drones” as “Loyal Wingman” (Air Force Research Laboratory), and in several other roles are simply early indicators that in some form, this is going to happen.

As reported in the July 2018 Mitchell Institute Policy Paper, “Manned-Unmanned Aircraft Teaming: Taking Combat Airpower to the Next Level”the USAF has a “serious capacity gap when it comes to fulfilling mission requirements with its current inventory”.  Later the paper notes that “to defend its interests around the globe,” America needs “a robust and varied toolkit.” The paper addresses roles to be filled by unmanned aircraft, bridging the capacity gap, logistics and much more.  It’s an enlightening read that incidentally touches on another Scorpion benefit demonstrated in this initiative, “the value of open missions systems for rapid integration of a variety of packages.”

Manned-Unmanned Aircraft Teaming: Taking Combat Airpower to the Next Level

The move towards MUM-T achieves a number of desirable outcomes; closes the capability gap positively with much lower costs than traditional systems; prioritizes unmanned systems for high threat areas; supports and empowers the information battlespace; may reduce impact of pilot shortage vs capability etc.. and more.

An interesting video of the demonstration shows the Scorpion’s cockpit with display of the integration with Synturian.  The demonstration utilized the Live, Virtual and Constructive (LVC) environment, with the Scorpion livein the air, the unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) in the virtualand the UAS sensors in the constructive.

This is one more example of the transformation that is the 21stcentury battlespace; MUM-T on a Scorpion with Synturian in an LVC environment. LVC is a training methodology that is critical to train cost effectively for missions in the 21stcentury battlespace.

The ability to function as a “node” in the 21stC battlespace space is no longer optional.  In LVC participants can experience multi-domain fusion warfare with simple or extraordinarily complex scenarios.

After flying the capability demonstration, Textron Aviation Defense Senior Flight Test Pilot, Brett Pierson commented; “The tactical and operational ramifications of this new capability are enormous.

“Further extending Scorpion’s sensor suite and penetrating a weather layer to generate target coordinates; or creating a triangulated solution independently; or adding layers to a multi-spectral fused solution, deliver an entirely new set of tactical capabilities that have never been possible in a fighter-typed aircraft.”

The capability to extend the kill web through MUM-T is a desirable capability, particularly with new stand-off munitions like the Raytheon SDB-II.

Such a combination certainly extends the mission set and capability of the Scorpion giving it the ability to execute ISR and attack missions at some distance into hostile space – from the relative safety of a more permissive airspace.

Textron extols a similar business model with the Scorpion as has been applied to the smartphone.

In which case, the Synturian System and MUM-T capability looks like a compelling “App” in the Scorpion’s “App store.”

Also see the following:

Textron Systems and Simulated Manned-Unmanned Teaming Capability

Editor’s Note: When Michael W. Wynne was Secretary of the Air Force, he explicitly focused on linking the benefits of the F-35 able to manage complex air space with weapons and unmanned systems in what he called the wolfpack concept. 

The complexity of airspace management is a key challenge facing teaming of weapons, manned and unmanned systems and the inherent capabilities of the F-35 is seen by Secretary Wynne as a key enabler of evolution in this combat area.

Shaping the Wolfpack: Leveraging the 5th Generation Revolution